Regretting You Review: It Ends With Us was a huge hit, and fans of Colleen Hoover expected another emotional whirlwind with Regretting You. The movie, released on October 23, 2025, takes us to a very lifeless follow-up. Regretting You was directed by Josh Boone, and it turned out to be a lifeless follow-up that struggles to balance its melodrama and emotional core. The movie had a promising cast in the form of Allison Williams, Dave Franco, Scott Eastwood, and Willa Fitzgerald, but it fails to live up to the raw chemistry and emotional impact that made its predecessor a hit.
Read Also: ‘It Welcome to Derry’ Series Review (2025): Pennywise Returns in an Uneven But Intriguing Prequel
‘Regretting You’ Movie Overview
- Release Date: October 24, 2025
- Director: Josh Boone
- Stars: Allison Williams, Mckenna Grace, Dave Franco, Mason Thames, Sam Morelos, Scott Eastwood, Willa Fitzgerald, and Clancy Brown
- Runtime: 116 minutes
- Banner: Harbinger Pictures, Frayed Pages Entertainment, & Heartbones Entertainment
- Rating: 2/5
Regretting You Plot
Regretting You takes us to Morgan (Allison Williams), her husband Chris (Scott Eastwood), and their teenage daughter Clara (McKenna Grace). The story plays between past and present and reveals the tangled relationships among Morgan, her sister Jenny (Willa Fitzgerald), and her best friend Jonah (Dave Franco). However, after a car crash that involved both Chris and Jenny, Morgan discovered their shocking secret affair.
The film is well-balanced as it attempts to explore grief, betrayal, and forgiveness. However, the film’s pacing and uneven tone are disturbing, and they make it hard to connect emotionally. The plot misses the track, and it comes across as an oddly restrained package.
‘Regretting You’ Review: Casts Performances
Allison Williams, who is best remembered for Girls and M3GAN, has delivered a grounded and heartfelt performance as a woman who navigates between heartbreak and self-discovery. Her portrayal of Morgan’s pain and resilience was the best thing that happened to Regretting You. Dave Franco, as Jonah, offers moments of quiet yearning, but their chemistry lacks spark.
Meanwhile, McKenna Grace does her best as Clara. She was good as a teenager, dealing with angst and confusion. However, the script gives her little to work with beyond predictable coming-of-age tropes. The supporting cast, despite strong resumes, didn’t come together, and they presented a disaster on the screen.
Read Also: Boston Blue Series Review (2025): A Promising New Chapter in the Blue Bloods Universe
Direction and Screenplay: A Case of Diminishing Returns
Josh Boone was famously known for “The Fault in Our Stars (2014),” and he tried bringing a glossy and mechanical feel to the film. However, it didn’t turn out well. The screenplay by Susan McMartin in Regretting You feels formulaic because of the recycled emotional beats and dialogue that borders on cliché. The attempt to recreate the heartfelt tone of It Ends With Us falters, and it is mainly due to the lack of narrative rhythm and genuine chemistry between characters.
Visually, Regretting You looks like a mid-budget release rather than a theatrical feature. Its muted cinematography and lifeless pacing will drain viewers’ energy.
Themes: Love, Loss, and Regret Without Resonance
Regretting You tells the story of the impact of grief on relationships. However, the film is a confusing phenomenon, as it fails to commit fully to its romantic and tragic aspects. One minute, it leans into heavy family drama, and the next, it slips into light rom-com territory, and this decreases its impact.
There are fleeting glimpses of authenticity. Clara’s impulsive reaction to her mother’s new relationship feels good, but it vanishes before achieving real catharsis. The emotional moments feel rushed, and this leaves viewers unmoved.
Read Also: Black Phone 2 Review: Ethan Hawke Returns for a Gripping and Gruesome Sequel
Baap of Movies Conclusion
All in all, Regretting You is that one film that was poised to cement Colleen Hoover’s growing presence in Hollywood, but it’s a huge disappointment. Regretting You is a missed opportunity that is very bland and has wasted a talented cast and rich source material.
Regretting You had been released in cinemas on October 24, 2025, but despite its promising premise, the film failed to translate into compelling cinema.
Watch Regretting You Trailer
Note
I hope this article is very useful for you. If you like this article, please share it with your friends and family, and also let us know your queries in the comments.
Read Also: Nobody Wants This Season 2 Review (2025): Netflix’s Rom-Com Returns with Charm but Misses Its Magic
