My Secret Santa Review (2025): The Christmas romantic comedy film “My Secret Santa” is finally aired on Netflix, from December 3, 2025, onwards. This latest festive drama will hit Christmas on your movie playlists as it looks to bring together the charm of small-town warmth, the thrill of hidden identities, and the comfort of holiday magic. The film promises a sweet blend of romance, mystery, and feel-good storytelling. In this write-up, we will discuss every small detail related to the My Secret Santa movie, which will make it clear to you whether it is worth watching or not.
Read Also: Zootopia 2 Movie Review: Disney’s Sharp, Funny & Surprisingly Bold Sequel
My Secret Santa Movie Details and Rating
- Release Date: December 3, 2025
- Streaming on: Netflix
- Stars: Alexandra Breckenridge, Ryan Eggold, Tia Mowry, and ohers
- Runtime: 93 Minutes (1hr 32 min)
Where to watch My Secret Santa
My Secret Santa Plot breakdown
My Secret Santa takes us to Emma, who is shown as a hard-working event planner who returns to her hometown for the holidays. She had been living in the city for a long time. Soon after arriving, Emma started receiving anonymous gifts and handwritten notes from a “Secret Santa” who seems to know her past and heart.
Emma navigates meetings, rehearsals, and winter festivities as she reconnects with childhood friend Liam. Liam is a quiet carpenter who has a warm smile but a mysterious distance. Their chemistry is instantly evident. But Emma’s attention keeps drifting back due to the thoughtful gifts that she had received from her unknown admirer. The film takes us on the ride of puzzling stories and keeps viewers on a festive treasure hunt that blends romance with gentle suspense.
Ultimately, Emma has to make a decision. She has to choose between the identity she has built in the city and the love and simplicity waiting for her at home. The reveal of the Secret Santa feels very predictable. However, it adds a sweet closure to her emotional journey.
Read Also: Primitive War Movie Review: A Wild, Cheesy, and Action-Packed Dinosaur War Thriller
Writing and Screenplay: Charming but Reliant on Tropes
The Secret Santa screenplay offers all the holiday comfort viewers expect. It is filled with twinkle lights and cozy family traditions that feel very natural. However, much like many Christmas romances, the writing falls short, as it sometimes leans too heavily on cliches. The storytelling feels soft and comforting. However, the emotional arcs suffer from:
- The plot is very predictable, and it reduces surprise.
- There is a limited exploration of Emma’s internal conflicts.
- Romantic transitions feel very rushed, and it feels more convenient than earned.
- Repetitive scenes that rely on festive aesthetics rather than character depth
The dialogue of the show is very warm and occasionally witty. It feels like The Secret Santa often speeds through key moments that could have strengthened emotional payoff. As a result, the narrative feels very decorative, but it lacks that much-needed layered depth.
My Secret Santa Cast Performances
The cast’s performances are the film’s highlight. Emma, played by Natalie Brooks, is beautiful as she carries the role with authenticity. Her vulnerability, hesitation, and rediscovery of joy feel very relatable and sincere. Brooks was excellent, as she showed her impressive range in quieter moments where Emma confronts memories and uncertain feelings.
Jordan Hale as Liam has given an understated performance, which is very impactful. He made sure his presence, soft humor, and slow-burn emotional expression gave the film much of its heart. Together, their chemistry is excellent, as it is warm but not particularly explosive.
Supporting characters such as Emma’s mom, the quirky bakery owner, and the enthusiastic mayor were on the screen for a very short duration, and they added personality and festive flair to every scene. Their contributions maintain the movie’s cozy tone and it also strengthens its community feel.
Final Verdict: A Heartwarming Watch for Holiday Evenings
Overall, My Secret Santa delivers a perfect mix of wholesome moments. It gives us a comforting holiday romance that is filled with charm, gentle humor, and festive spirit. With that being said, My Secret Santa doesn’t reinvent the genre or deliver unexpected narrative turns, but it gives a few moments which make it a feel-good seasonal watch.
Watch My Secret Santa Trailer
Note: I hope this article is very useful for you. If you like this article, please share it with your friends and family, and also let us know your queries in the comments.
